Table of contents

  1. The adventures of ripping Blu-Ray discs (and 4K!)
  2. Obtaining the Blu-Ray player
  3. Buying some new movies
  4. The Return of the Living Dead 4K + Blu-Ray
  5. The Paul Naschy Collection (Blu-Ray)
  6. The Paul Naschy Collection II (Blu-Ray)
  7. The arrival
  8. Setting up
  9. Make-MKV
  10. Flashing the drive
  11. Ripping the discs' contents
  12. Creating ISO files

The adventures of ripping Blu-Ray discs (and 4K!)

Oh brother, what a treat!

For a very long time now, and you probably know about this if you know me already, I've been ripping ISOs of my DVD movies into my hard drive.
That way, I not only preserve the movie, but I can also have much easier and convenient access to them, as I no longer have to get my ass up from the seat and go find the disc or whatever.
Of course, I did have a couple of Blu-Rays, and was planning to buy more, but I would only really do so if I managed to figure out how to rip them, too. Unfortunately, this would prove to not only not be an easy task, but would also be quite expensive.

I originally tried using my modded PlayStation 3 to rip the Blu-Ray ISOs, using MultiMan.
While this technically worked, the ripped ISOs would be unencrypted. What does this mean?
Blu-Ray discs used a rather complex type of encryption compared to DVDs, called AACS. I'm not 100% sure how it works, but it basically works with a key exchange system.
Now, some of the Blu-Ray AACS keys were leaked a while ago, and can be downloaded and used with VLC and MakeMKV to play and rip the contents of SOME Blu-Rays. But not all of them, so really, this wasn't of much use to me. I had to find out a way to de-encrypt the ISOs.

There was a program that claimed to be able to do this, called AnyDVD. Unfortunately, I wasn't able to get it to work, and besides, it only had a free 30 day trial and the full version was quite expensive, plus, the damn program and its servers (which are required to download the keys database and activate your purchase license) have since disappeared.
So, really, the only way to properly do this... was to fucking do it. I would need to get an actual Blu-Ray player for my PC and use MakeMKV to rip and decrypt the movies.

Obtaining the Blu-Ray player

Thankfully, actually finding the correct player to find was rather easy.
There are a pair of YouTube videos where a guy basically tells you which one gives you the best bang for your buck, you can check them out here, but this post should be enough for you to learn how to do this without watching the videos.

Basically, the drive you'll want to buy is the LG WH14NS40.
It's supposed to be a standard Blu-Ray player, but it will actually work with 4K movies once we flash the firmware.
My experience with it so far has been great, although I have seen some people claim that theirs stopped working after a while. Hopefully I'm not in for a late surprise.

One thing to take in mind here is that it's a SATA drive. A USB drive would probably have been less of a hassle to use, specially for me, since I don't have any spare SATA slots, but those were much, MUCH more expensive.
The guy in the video does talk about a USB case you can buy, but it costs another 50$ so honestly I can't recommend it, unless you're using a laptop and simply can't use a SATA connection.

Now, I don't actually have any 4K Blu-Ray movies, hell, I don't even have that many Blu-Ray movies to begin with, so I also bought a couple of them to test the thing...

Buying some new movies

The Return of the Living Dead 4K + Blu-Ray

My first choice for a 4K movie was rather obvious... The Return of the Living Dead! BRAAAAAAAINS!!!!

I've been wanting to get this movie on Blu-Ray for a while, I had it on DVD but I really wanted to see all the detail on Trash'... uh, I mean, all the detail on Tarman's slimy body... yeah.
This release is made by Shout Factory, and it was really set out to be amazing, it has a ton of extras, like commentaries, a workprint of the movie, and even a restoration of the original theatrical audio track, with the real Tarman voice, which hadn't really been available at home since the VHS release of the movie.

The only problem is that it didn't come with Spanish (my native language) audio, so if I wanted to watch the movie with my family, I'd have to somehow put the audio from the DVD in there... but that's a story for another day.

The Paul Naschy Collection (Blu-Ray)

A nice and rather varied collection of Paul Naschy movies, mysteriously, their only (legal) Blu-Ray releases that exists, as far as I know... yes, only in the United States, not Spain.

In case you don't know, Paul Naschy was a famous (although, still pretty niche, all things considered) Spanish actor, mainly known for his horror movies, more specifically, his werewolf movies.

In the modern days, he's often called the "Spanish Lon Chaney", and he's actually pretty well known internationally, more than he is in Spain, actually.
Which, I suppose may explain why we haven't actually gotten a collection like this over here, save for the old DVD collection that had 8 movies split across 2 sets (none of them matching the movies in either Shout Factory collection, interestingly enough). Fun fact about that collection, it was one of the last properly legal and licensed releases of Resen and Llamentol, and was of fairly high quality and had nice extras.

The Paul Naschy Collection II (Blu-Ray)

The second and, unfortunately, last set of Paul Naschy movies released by Shout Factory.
Although I don't think this one's movies are as good as the first one's, it's still really good and a huge recommendation.

The worst thing I can definitely say about this set, is that they never made any more, which is really unfortunate, because Paul Naschy has nearly 100 movies under his belt, and many of them would really benefit from proper re-scans and remasters.
Hell, some of them I think are still stuck on VHS.
I guess we can only hope that Shout will one day decide to revisit Naschy's filmographies, and bring us more of his classic werewolf movies, as oddly enough, these two collections don't contain that many of them, and those who are here aren't the most popular.

I would specially like to see a remaster of The Beast and the Magic Sword. Also, please do a proper release of Tomb of the Werewolf! It's currently only available on BD-R...

The arrival

On 9/08/2024, the first part of the order arrived.
It contained the Blu-Ray burner, Return of the Living Dead, and the first Paul Naschy collection.

Unfortunately, the packages didn't arrive in perfect condition.
Thankfully, there was seemingly nothing wrong with the Blu-Ray burner, but the movies were slightly damaged. The Return of the Living Dead was the one in the worst condition, some of the case's plastic had broken off, so now the case can't be closed properly and the main 4K disc's holder is broken, so it doesn't hold the disc properly anymore.

The Paul Naschy Collection, albeit in better shape, also was slightly damaged, tho it was mostly in the corners and only in the cardboard cover.
Really, neither of these are really significant problems, specially when asking for a return would involve shipping this back to the US and the replacement would likely be damaged as well, but it is a little annoying.

As a side note, the second Paul Naschy collection, which arrived a few days later on Monday, was also slightly damaged.

Minor visual imperfections aside, everything was working in order, the discs and the burner, so let's set it all up and get working on ripping Blu-Rays!

Setting up

As I mentioned earlier, one of the main problems of this whole setup was that the Blu-Ray burner used a SATA connection, and I didn't really have any free SATA ports anymore.
So, what was the solution? Well, a rather crude one.

Whenever I want to use the burner to rip discs, I have to unplug one of my hard drives to free up a SATA slot. Now, the only hard drive I can easily remove is either one of the drives that I use for actually archiving the movies. But there's a problem with this... both of these drives are setup as one dynamic volume, for multiple reasons, mainly, that I need a folder with hard links to all the ISO files to use with PS3 Net Server, and of course they can't be spread across two drives (I promise, I'll make a blog about how to set that up too, at some point!).

So, before I unplug either two of the drives, I have to make sure I mark them as "offline" before shutting down the computer, otherwise, problems may show up (I'm not actually sure if they will, I don't really want to test it out, but I do it just to be sure).

Thankfully, simply disabling both discs and simply unplugging one works perfectly, without any sort of data corruption problems, so that's the setup I use.
Granted, it's pretty messy, both on the technical side and the physical side, if you look at the image... but, hey, if it works, it works.

Make-MKV

The first thing you'll need to do to rip Blu-Rays is to download and install Make-MKV, and if you need help installing the program... how did you even get here in the first place?

Now, it's important to note that the default installation of Make-MKV won't actually let you rip Blu-Rays, you'll need to activate the program.
Before you start searching for a Torrent, I should let you know that Make-MKV is in a sort of Win-RAR situation, where the program is technically not free, but it also technically is.
The program requires a license key, and you can get a permanent one by buying it, but the creator releases new free public keys on a monthly basis in the Make-MKV forums.
Of course, that means that you have to renew the key every month, but I don't think that's much of a hassle.

Once you've registered, closed and re-opened Make-MKV, and if you've bought the same drive as me, you should see a screen similar to this:

Now, there are a lot of fields here, but these are the ones you should be on the look-out for:

  • Drive Information
  • Product: BD-RE WH14NS40
  • Revision: 1.05
  • LibreDrive Information
  • Status: Possible (with patched firmware)
  • Drive platform: MT1959
  • Hardware support: Yes
  • Firmware version: 1.05

If any of this doesn't match what you see on your Make-MKV window, you should stop the process right now and do some research on your drive before continuing, or you will most likely end up bricking it.

Flashing the drive

The next thing we need to do to get this working is to flash the firmware of our drive by using a tool called SDFTool.
Once you've downloaded it, you should see a window similar to this. Make sure to select your Blu-Ray drive on the drop-down menu, and then select the READ option, because we'll first be making a backup of the original firmware, just in case something goes wrong or you need to return the drive.

Once that's done, make sure you store the ripped .BIN file in a safe place that you will remember, you never know when you'll need it.
Now, you must download the all in one firmware pack that you'll find on the Make-MKV forum thread.
It comes with a bunch of patched firmwares for different drives, but the one we're interested in (if you're using the same drive as us) is the one that's located inside the LG 5.25 desktop folder, named HL-DT-ST-BD-RE_WH16NS60-1.02-NM00100-211810291936.bin.
You may have noticed it's not actually named after the model of the drive we bought, but a later one also made by LG. However, it works with both models, so we'll be using that one.

Select the WRITE option on SDFTool, pick the correct file and then click on START, and wait for the firmware to be flashed.

Once that's done, you should close and re-open Make-MKV, or even reboot your computer if you want to be safe (I didn't need to, I simply re-opened Make-MKV for it to detect the changes), and you should see that it can now actually rip Blu-Rays, and even 4K Blu-Rays!
Again, make sure the information on your screen matches what's on the image, otherwise, you may not have flashed your firmware correctly.

Ripping the discs' contents

Now that we've flashed the drive's firmware, really, we're done, we just have to actually rip the discs now.
There are two main ways of getting the contents out of the disc, the first one, which a lot of people use, is to simply extract the video files in the disc into MKV containers.
I personally don't like this method, as I like to preserve the menus of the DVD's, even those that aren't particularly great, so we'll use the other method, the backup option.
It's the folder icon with a green arrow in Make-MKV.

Once you use that option, Make-MKV will commence the process of ripping the whole disc, menus and everything.
MAKE SURE YOU CHECK THE DECRYPT VIDEO FILES OPTION!!!!
You wouldn't wanna end up with useless, encrypted files, right?

Now, once the process is done, those of you who are used to ripping DVD's with Make-MKV might find a liiiiitle issue. Where's the ISO file???

But don't panic just yet. This is normal.
For whatever reason, Make-MKV does not create ISO files of Blu-Ray and 4K movies, it simply extracts all contents into a folder.
But, this folder is essentially the same as the ISO file, so really, we just need to create an ISO of it.
Although, you technically CAN just use this folder, VLC should be able to just play the .m2ts files inside the BDMV/STREAM folder, and Make-MKV can still rip the video files if you point it to either the index.bdmv or MovieObject.bdmv file inside the BDMV folder.

And that brings us to...

Creating ISO files

The best piece of software for this, IMO, is IMG Burn. It's rather easy and intuitive to use, and you can see this right in the main screen. Simply click the giant Create image file from files/folder button:

This will open a new screen, where you should select the folder containing the BDMV, CERTIFICATE and MAKEMKV folders as the source, and then simply pick a destination file-name, and then click the big build button at the bottom to create your ISO file!

And there you go!
You should now have an usable ISO file of your Blu-Ray or 4K disc. Of course, Make-MKV will still work with DVD's using your new Blu-Ray burner.
However, one thing that is worth noting, is that I haven't been able to play all the ISO files with VLC or even Media Player Classic, some of them crash both programs (specifically, it seems to happen with the Paul Naschy movies and the bonus disc of Return of the Living Dead) even though the .m2ts files played without issues.

However, I'm still able to extract the .MKV files from the ISOs with Make-MKV, and can mount the ISOs on my PS3 just fine without any trouble, so it must be a bug with both media players or something.
Still, I thought it was important to note.

And that's it for now! I hope this was of some use, I look forward to bringing you more useful tutorials.

Back to the blog section

This page is currently under construction!
Please, be patient!